Patent trolling: negative impact and need for protection
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31558/2307-2318.2020.3.25Keywords:
patenting; patent trolling; intellectual property; royalties; competition; inventions; trademarkAbstract
Patenting of products, technologies and designs for manufacturers should be one of the key elements of the production process. Intellectual property and enterprise innovation are increasingly being the subject of illegal actions, so-called «Patent Trolling». The result of patent trolling for the manufacturer (importer) or seller can be unforeseen losses from litigation, product delays at the border, loss of foreign partners, loss of image and reputation.
As a result of the analysis made such a phenomenon as «Patent Trolling» and the need for patenting products was investigated. The key benefits of patenting for the manufacturer have been identified and characterized. Considered what is a patent and the rights granted by the patent to the owner. It is determined which result of intellectual and creative activity is subject to patenting. The state and tendencies of patenting in Ukraine are investigated. The peculiarities of the activity of patent trolls in the world and in Ukraine are analyzed and compared. The mechanism of patent troll’s activity in Ukraine and abroad is developed. The main reasons for the emergence of patent trolling in Ukraine are identified and ways to overcome it at the legislative level are formed. These measures will help the manufacturer to avoid patent trolling and minimize its impact on economic activity.
The patent gives the owner (manufacturer) the opportunity to single-handedly produce a unique product, take a leading position in the market, receive royalties, and protect products and reputation from the actions of unfair competitors and patent trolls. Patent trolling causes great damage to industry and the country. After all, with each case of patent trolling the country loses its image, investment attractiveness, foreign exporters and reduced imports of Ukrainian goods. The solution to this problem is possible if manufacturers (importers) will use the right to patent the product, as well as change the legislation on patenting products.
References
Litsenziia na vykorystannia obiekta prava intelektualnoi vlasnosti [License to use the object of intellectual property rights]. (n.d.). www.pidru4niki.com. Retrieved from https://pidru4niki.com/1109032447948/pravo/litsenziya_vikoristannya_obyekta_prava_intele ktualnoyi_vlasnosti [in Ukrainian]
Zakon Ukrainy «Pro okhoronu prav na vynakhody i korysni modeli» zi zminamy vid 16.10.2012 № 5460-VI [Law of Ukraine «On protection of rights to inventions and utility models» of 23.12.1993 № 3769-ХІІ with changes of 16.10.2012 № 5460-VI]. (2014). Vidomosti verkhovnoi rady – Verkhovna Rada Data, 2-3, 41 [in Ukrainian]
Promyslova vlasnist u tsyfrakh. Pokaznyky u sferi promyslovoi vlasnosti za 2019 rik [Industrial property in numbers. Indicators in the field of industrial property for 2019]. (2020). www.ukrpatent.org. Retrieved from https://ukrpatent.org/atachs/promvlasnist-2019.pdf [in Ukrainian]
Sait «Reanematsiinyi paket reform» [Site «Reanimation Package of Reforms»]. (2018). www.rpr.org.ua. Retrieved from https://rpr.org.ua/news/100-mln-hrn-schorichnovyplachujetsya-v-ukrajini-yak-royalti-u-polschi-v-50-raziv-bilshe/ [in Ukrainian]
The Global Competitiveness Report. (2019). www3.weforum.org. Retrieved from http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_TheGlobalCompetitivenessReport2019.pdf [in English]
Report on the Protection and Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights in Third Countries. (2019). www.trade.ec.europa.eu. Retrieved from https://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/ docs/2020/january/tradoc_158561.pdf [in English]
Create. U.S. Chamber International Index. Sixth Edition. (2018). www.globalipcenter.wpengine.com. Retrieved from http://globalipcenter.wpengine.com//wpcontent/uploads/2018/02/GIPC_IP_Index_2018.pdf [in English]
Cherkashin I. (2016). Zlovzhyvannia pravom intelektualnoi vlasnosti (patentnyi trolinh) [Abuse of intellectual property rights (patent trolling)]. www.ukrainepravo.com. Retrieved from http://ukrainepravo.com/scientificthought/pravova-pozytsiya/zlovzhivannya-pravom-ntelektu alno-vlasnostpatentniy-trol-ng-/ [in Ukrainian]
Shcho robyty, yakshcho na shliakhu vstav patentnyi trol? [What to do if a patent troll gets in the way?]. (2018). www.lexinform.com.ua. Retrieved from https://lexinform.com.ua/yuridychna-praktyka/shho-robyty-yakshho-na-shlyahu-vstav-patentn yj-trol/ [in Ukrainian]
Okhromieiev Yu. (2015). Patentnyi trolinh – akhillesova piata systemy okhorony intelektualnoi vlasnosti v Ukraini [Patent trolling is the Achilles heel of the intellectual property protection system in Ukraine]. Yurydychna hazeta online – Legal newspaper online. Retrieved from https://yur-gazeta.com/dumka-eksperta/patentniy-troling--ahillesova-pyata-sistemiohoroni-intelektualnoyi-vlasnosti-v-ukrayini.html [in Ukrainian]
Hayes A. (2020). Patent Troll. www.investopedia.com. Retrieved from https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/patent-troll.asp [in English]
Klos M. (2020). How IPCom kept the mobile phone industry on tenterhooks for 13 years. Official web-site IPCom. Retrieved from https://www.ipcom-munich.com/post/how-ipcomkept-the-mobile-phone-industry-on-tenterhooks-for-13-years [in English]
Cherkashin I., Nazarchuk B. (2016). «Patentnyi trolinh» yak peredumova do zahostrennia suspilno-politychnoi sytuatsii v derzhavi ta formuvannia nehatyvnoho imidzhu Ukrainy na mizhnarodnii areni (za prykladom Zhytomyrskoi oblasti) [«Patent trolling" as a prerequisite for the aggravation of the socio-political situation in the country and the formation of a negative image of Ukraine in the international arena (following the example of Zhytomyr region)]. Journal of Kyiv University of Law. Retrieved from http://ir.znau.edu.ua/bitstream/123456789/5844/1/CHKUP_2016_2_260-264.pdf [in Ukrainian]
Izhevska M. (2019). Patentnyi trolinh: kytaitsi sudiatsia z ukraintsem za brend AliExpress. [Patent trolling: the Chinese are suing a Ukrainian for the AliExpress brand. Wisegroup. Retrieved from https://wisegroup.com.ua/ua/patentnij-troling-kitajci-sudyatsya-zukra%D1%97ncem-za-brend-aliexpress/ [in Ukrainian]
Konovalenko V. (2018). Shcho robyty, yakshcho na shliakhu vstav patentnyi trol? [What to do if a patent troll gets in the way?]. LexInform. Retrieved from https://lexinform.com.ua/yuridychna-praktyka/shho-robyty-yakshho-na-shlyahu-vstav-patentn yj-trol/ [in Ukrainian]